Georgia State Election Board chair says all he’s seen is a “very smooth, well-run” election

John Fervier, chairman of Georgia’s State Election Board, is a mild-mannered corporate executive with a dry wit and an aversion to the spotlight. Yet in recent weeks he found himself at the center of a political storm as three of his MAGA-oriented board members pushed through rules that many believed would have caused chaos and confusion in Georgia during the presidential election. 

The pro-Trump faction, which forms a majority of the board, passed one rule that would have required county election officials to hand-count every paper ballot on election night and another rule that required a “reasonable inquiry” before an election could be certified. 

Both rules were ultimately rejected by Georgia courts, though the rulings have been appealed. Fervier talked to CBS News —his first sit down with a national outlet— about how he thinks the election has gone so far and what he’s expecting in the coming days. 

The interview has been condensed and lightly edited for clarity.

Dan Klaidman:  How’s the election going so far from your vantage point? You’ve been out there, traveling around, talking to poll workers, election administrators.  

John Fervier: As chairman of the state election board, I felt it was necessary for me to have boots on the ground, to go out there and see what’s actually happening, specifically for Fulton County, because there were a lot of allegations, mostly unfounded allegations, from the 2020 election. 

But I also wanted to see what was going on across the state. So last week, I was in South Georgia, I visited Camden County, visited Glynn County, and I have been to several locations in Gwinnett County. Now I’ve been to nine different locations in Fulton County.  I’ve visited close to 15 polling locations now, and all I’ve seen is a very smooth, well-run, well-organized election. 

I talked to people operating the poll pads, to voters. I talked to these security officers, and I talk to all the election monitors, whether they’re from the Democratic Party, Republican Party, or even the Libertarian Party, I just want to get their feeling of how things are going. I feel confident with the laws and the policies and procedures that are in place that we have a very secure election.

Klaidman:  You mentioned Fulton County, which was the object of a lot of the controversy back in 2020 and threats against poll workers —and people, including former President Trump, casting doubt on whether they ran a fair election. This past weekend, the state Republican party filed lawsuits over the county’s decision to allow people to drop off absentee ballots after the Friday deadline. A judge rejected their claim.

Fervier: Well, it’s a lot of disinformation being put out there. It’s people that just don’t understand or are actually just trying to create chaos. 

There is no prohibition in statute of law that would keep a county from keeping their registrar’s office open on the weekend to collect absentee ballots. Some people want to say they’re continuing voting or continue doing this or that? No, it’s just people that are just dropping off their absentee ballots. They could drop them off at the post office. They can hand them over at the register’s office. They can hand them in on Election Day or during early voting period, or on the weekends if that’s what the county so desires. And that’s not against the statute.

Klaidman:  So you think this is an effort to sow distrust in the election, or to suppress the vote?

Fervier:  I don’t understand why anybody opposed it. Frankly, if you’re worried about ballot security, you should be in favor of this because they’re actually delivering them to a registrar and not putting a truckload of them in a mailbox someplace. So to me, I don’t know why you’d be opposed to this, and I’ve seen some people online using this to try to create chaos. 

Russia election interference in Georgia

Klaidman: The FBI and U.S. intelligence community have said Russia has tried to interfere with the U.S. election.  Last week the FBI linked a video purporting to show voter fraud in Georgia to Russian influence actors.  

Fervier: To me, the bigger threat is the organic stuff that’s coming from within our country. You know, there are groups of people out there, they call themselves the Patriots or the Proud Boys or Antifa or whatever, and those are the ones that scare me more than the Russian bots, because they have organized groups out there that cause issues. 

I’ve seen that on the State Election Board. You’ll have these people that will just gin up all this anxiety over issues and they’re just trying to create chaos and sow doubt and confusion in the election. 

Klaidman: Have you seen any evidence of fraud?

Fervier: You got 5 to 7 million people voting. There’s going to be some small issues, but they want to talk about illegal immigrants voting. In my time on the board, I’ve never seen a case yet (involving) illegal immigrants (that) has come before the board. 

They want to talk about all these dead people voting. I haven’t seen that. 

Have there been instances of people double voting? Yes, there’s always going to be that. There’s always going to be those onesies and twosies out there. That’s going to happen. But this mass amount of people, they talk about mass amounts of dead people, or mass amount of illegal immigrants, or massive amount of anything, it’s just not happening. It’s not reality. But if you listen to some of these people on the internet or on Twitter you would think it’s just a big problem. It’s just not.

Klaidman: As the chairman of the State Election Board, (you) have been at the center of a controversy in Georgia over this election on the board itself.  The MAGA-oriented majority pushed through some rules that could have delayed certification of the election, including a requirement that ballots be handcounted to ensure that (they) matched the number counted by machines, as well as one that allowed for a “reasonable inquiry” to look into potential fraud before certification.  What do you think those board members’ motives were?

Fervier: You’ll have to ask them their motive.  My positions for opposing these are well known, and I state them in the board meetings themselves. They think that these rules will enhance security of the elections. I don’t share that opinion with them. 

Some of these rules seem to be fairly innocuous, until you start understanding exactly how they work. I oppose them because I don’t think they’re grounded in statute or allowed by law.  I’m a small-government kind of guy. I don’t believe in the power of boards. I believe in the power of the legislature. The legislature is the ones that should be making election law, not state boards. 

Anxieties about election boards and certification

Klaidman: There’s been concern, not just in Georgia but around the country, that some of these local election boards may simply refuse to certify their elections. 

Fervier: The statute says that at 5 p.m. on the Monday following the election, the board “shall certify” the results of the election. It doesn’t say “maybe.” It doesn’t say “probably.” They have no discretion there.  

Klaidman: How concerned are you that one or more members of one of these boards refuse to certify as an act of civil disobedience? 

Fervier: Well, I think that’s likely to happen, having —frankly, I’ll be shocked if there wasn’t anyone in the state of Georgia that didn’t refuse to certify. I would be more concerned if I thought that a (full) board refused to certify. I think that that creates a significant problem. An individual won’t stop the certification. I am greatly concerned about if a board refuses to.

Klaidman: What recourse is there if that happens?

Fervier: If an individual refuses certifying, I could see somebody bringing a case before the state election board because they refuse to follow the law. It’ll be interesting to see if that occurs. We can also refer cases to the attorney general’s office or the local D.A. for prosecution.

Why is the election denial movement still strong?

Klaidman: What sort of insights have you gleaned over this past almost year, since you’ve been on the board about this election denial movement that’s been such a stubborn part of our politics?

Fervier: I don’t think people give enough credit to the chaos and confusion that was caused by COVID. In the 2020 election, when you had counties that found it very difficult to hire election workers or qualified election workers, you had people that wouldn’t go to the polls and vote by absentee ballot in record numbers. I think that there was a lot of human error that occurred in 2020 but I have yet to see any actual fraud, and I’ve looked at hundreds, if not thousands of pages of evidence that’s been put before me. And all that (alleged) fraud has been disproven time and time again, by the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, by the FBI, by reporters, by Republicans, by Democrats. I mean, it’s been disproven, and yet people can’t seem to get past it.

Threats against election officials as tensions rise

Klaidman: Many have heard about Ruby Freeman and her daughter Shay Moss, poll workers in Fulton County who were the targets of horrific threats of violence and racial attacks. What is your sense of the threat environment right now, a day before the election?

Fervier: I would tell you that for our board, the threats were spiking back in the August-September time frame, when all the rules were being proposed for our board. They’ve significantly reduced in the last couple weeks. 

Klaidman: You received death threats? 

Fervier: I’ve received some.  But as I go around to the polls, I haven’t heard of a single instance of any threats. There was only two instances I’ve heard of where the police had to be notified, and it was because voters were wearing campaigning gear that they shouldn’t have been wearing. You’re not allowed to wear partisan gear within 150 feet of the polls.  

Klaidman: Are you worried about physical violence?

Fervier: I think that we need to be prepared for it. There are crazy people out there, crazy people on the right and the left, and emotions and passions are high. Every polling place I’ve been at has had security officers there, which gives me a lot of confidence, and gives the voters and election workers a lot of confidence.  It’s something we have to be concerned about but I haven’t heard of or seen any threats yet.

Klaidman: We used to take for granted that the people who administer our elections did so in a nonpartisan way. Can we still do that?

Fervier: We’ve all got opinions. The question is whether you can be nonpartisan in your work. My position is nonpartisan by statute, and I take that extremely seriously. I don’t care if you’re a Democrat or Republican, libertarian, Green Party. It doesn’t matter to me — everybody deserves a voice. Everybody deserves to vote. And it’s extremely important to me that all of us in the election system, whether it’s the poll workers or the poll superintendents or the boards or anybody, act in a nonpartisan manner. 

Klaidman: What’s your day look like on Election Day? 

Fervier: Busy, busy, busy. I’m going to start out at 7 a.m. in the polls and probably finish up at midnight with the secretary of state’s office, watching all the returns come in. I would like to hit 10 to 15 polls during the day at least. And when I go into a poll, I want to shake the hand of every poll worker there, because I am extremely grateful for the hard work and the time and their patience and what they’ve done over the last three, four weeks in bringing about a safe and secure election for Georgia. These people work hard, and they deserve our appreciation.